Here's the next installment of my lengthy tome. Please click here for Parts One through Three.~ Part Four~
My "I love you" hung in the air for a few seconds. I didn't regret saying it because, well, she initiated it. I wasn't running the risk that she took when she uttered that staggering phrase first. But I was still petrified. I was normally such an emotional control freak and here I had just surrendered a sizable chunk of my tightly-wound turf.
I sweated it out for a few more moments. And then, finally, she replied. Apparently, she was in shock. A giddy, mind-racing, heart-fluttering good kind of shock, but shock nonetheless.
Her: Oh my God. I'm just... I'm sorry. I'm stunned. Do you know how happy you just made me? Do you have ANY idea?
Me: Wow. I actually said it.
Her: Yes, you did! I'm so proud of you. Oh my God, I'm so happy right now!
Me: Wow. I actually said it.
Her: Are you okay?
Me: Yes. I'm fine. I'm just... Wow. I actually said it. Sorry I'm being so stupid. I do love you too. And I mean it. I do. I'm just sorry I couldn't say it before, you know?
Her: It's okay. You don't have to apologize. I know that was huge for you. You don't need to explain.
But I did try to explain, as best I could, and we ended up talking for several more hours. She admitted that my response had sent her reeling. She said that I had at last given her what she had hoped for but wasn't at all expecting.
Eventually and hesitantly we finally signed off after a busy night of breakthroughs and brand-new connections.
The next day, she sent me a note:
From the very beginning, all I've ever wanted was to be close to you. You have no idea how happy you've made me.
When I read it, my hands turned clammy and cold. I started to shake. I became really uncomfortable. I was suddenly embarrassed by her openness... and my own the night before. I didn't want to be reminded of it the next day.
My response to her was completely dependent on the time of day. A pattern was emerging. At night, I was completely swept up in this relationship that defied all common sense and definition. By day, I wrote it off as foolish drunken behavior. In the harsh daylight, it made no sense. The efficacy of her magic diminished after a good night's sleep.
Each day I tried to be practical and remind myself that even though I spoke to her day in and day out and broke daring new ground, we still had no business talking to each other in this manner. She had a boyfriend, for fuck's sake! And I, with my new-found confidence thanks to her, was still giving it the old college try with the boys, albeit at much better establishments than before.
My friend had just started medical school and was introducing me to eligible soon-to-be doctors left and right. A couple of them had a keen interest in me so I flirted and followed the script but really, I couldn't care less. I was just passing the time until last call. Attention from boys was no longer a measure of success. I didn't need the attention nor did I really want it. In a weird, fucked-up, totally incomprehensible way, I already had someone to come home to at night.
But then again, she was a girl six years younger than me, lived in Oklahoma and uh, hello, we were both straight! Or at least she was. I didn't know what to think about myself at this point. I wasn't having lesbian fantasies about her necessarily but I did want to go to Tulsa and just sweep her off her feet. And, you know, maybe kick her boyfriend's ass.
I'd sometimes catch myself in the middle of this daydream and become instantly appalled. I had no idea where my head was at. I chastised myself repeatedly. Oh the migraines and the maddening debate she caused! My mind fluctuated back and forth between sheer logic and a growing desire that I really didn't understand. It was dizzying.
But all I had to do was just think about her and it calmed me down. And, somehow, I knew that she was out there thinking about me and struggling with the same things.
It was insane and scary and I tried more than once to put the brakes on it but good God, I was drunk on her and how she made me feel. We each tried to get back on the "normal" friendship track but it was really no use. We were out of control and we both knew it.
In our correspondence, we'd nervously laugh (as well as you can through digital communication) and joke about how lovey-dovey and schmoopie we were. We always followed up these conversations with a proclamation of our non-gayness. Regrettably, the discourse was often far from enlightened. Whereas the rejection and vehement denial of homosexual tendencies sometimes takes the form of physical violence, she and I stooped to its equally vile verbal counterpart.
Because we weren't gay, you see. We were just two female friends who thought the world of each other and had an indescribable connection. We chanted this mantra repeatedly in the hopes that maybe we'd actually start to believe it ourselves.
In early 1998
Annie Get Your Gun was preparing for its Broadway run. Being a fellow Bernadette devotee, she wanted to come to New York to see the show. She booked her flight and I got us tickets for the show. I forwarded her the Ticketmaster confirmation and attached the note:
Here's hoping we don't act like retards this time around.
Prior to this trip, she and I had spent about 60 minutes together total. Somewhere in between the "You're beautiful" and the "I love you too" stages, she came to New York for a quick visit.
Some of the details surrounding her first trip are kind of fuzzy. I view this as a bit of a victory because there was a time when I remembered everything in excruciating detail and tortured myself with it. I couldn't let it go. Obviously, my recollection is still intact but I'm grateful that my memory of her is no longer photographic. I have to work harder to patch together the timeline and specifics.
As I recall, I was so scared of meeting her face-to-face that I did everything in my power to make myself almost unavailable. She aimed rather high when trying to claim some of my time but I somehow talked her down to a mid-week lunch hour. I blamed it on being busy but really, I wanted and needed a time limit and an escape route.
As much as I wanted to see her, I felt weird. This person, who up until then only existed in a still photo and Times New Roman font, was about to become real. VERY real. And in addition to feeling, I dunno,
funny about her, I also felt self-conscious about our age difference. I was a vain 24 year old and I thought I was far too grown up to be hanging out with a high school kid. Even if that high school kid was her, my beautiful little girl. At the time, I either couldn't or simply refused to reconcile the two.
The plan was that she'd call me when she arrived in New York and we'd finalize our plans. I came home one night and the light on my answering machine was flashing. While I watched it blink, I considered what her voice might sound like. This would be my first exposure to it, after all. Would she sound all twangy like Garth Brooks? He was the only other Oklahoman I knew. Oh my God, would she call me m'am? I ran through a gallery of famous Southern drawls in my head. I had manufactured a short list of good and bad Southern accents. I said a quick prayer that she wouldn't fall into the latter category.
Let's take a time out for a second, shall we, to consider the gall on this girl from Jersey -- of all places -- being disdainful of and overly concerned about an annoying-sounding regional dialect. What balls! Or, more accurately, what
bawwwwwls!
I hit the playback button and I immediately smiled. She didn't sound at all like the cartoonish hillbilly I had imagined. On the contrary, her voice was lovely. She was a trained singer so it was rich and resonant with only a subtle shade of Okie to it. Her accent warmed her voice. It felt cozy and familiar, like my security blanket.
We played phone tag a bit but by her second night in town, we managed to track each other down. We blabbed and blabbed and blabbed and eight hours later, we finally hung up. I could have spoken to her for another eight easily.
I already regretted only allotting one hour of my time during her stay.
She met me outside of my office the next day. My heart was in my throat as I scanned the crowds looking for her. I stole nervous-yet-reassuring glances at my shoes. Monitoring my fidgeting legs and tapping feet was my only coping mechanism.
I looked up just as she turned the corner. She immediately caught my eye and we both smiled and inched closer to each other.
After the long phone call and the countless hours spent writing to each other, you would think that we would instantly embrace in a warm, friendly hug. I'm pretty sure she was game for one but for reasons I can't explain, I thrust out my hand and said, "It's nice to finally meet you."
I shook her hand? What?!?!
She looked a little surprised as she accepted my handshake and said, "Oh! Um, it's nice to meet you too."
I was a total tool. But she was by no means cool and collected either. She was visibly nervous and looking to me for cues. I, being the social retard that I am, was of no help or comfort. I could barely look her in the eyes. I assumed a maddeningly business-like attitude and played tour guide as we walked to the restaurant.
We were both confused by our own discomfort. She and I had really charted a lot of intense territory and here I was, in person, incapable of anything more personal than, "Whatever you do, don't eat at the All-Star Cafe. That place sucks. I mean, I haven't actually eaten there myself but just trust me. Don't bother."
We eventually managed to calm down a bit as the hour progressed. We chatted and giggled. Over those 60 minutes, we were very much the two female friends we often offered up as evidence in support of the argument that ours was a unique but
strictly hetero relationship.
Our time was up. As we said our goodbyes, I was actually able to initiate a hug. It was a small step towards bridging the gap between our written connection and our face-to-face one. I wanted more time with her so that in person, we could achieve a consistent level of comfort. But my lunch hour was over and she had Broadway shows to watch, museums to visit and souvenirs to buy.
My being over-protective and stingy with my time had come back to bite me in the ass. We lingered for a second and I said, "Okay, I really have to go." She cocked her head to the side and her mouth formed just the hint of a pout as she said, "Aw." That small gesture caused an eruption of butterflies in my stomach.
I gave her another hug -- this one with an extra squeeze at the end -- and ducked into my office building, a little sad, a bit relieved and beyond baffled.
She emailed me when she got back to Oklahoma a few days later. After the discussion of musicals and museums, we turned to the topic of our shared case of nerves. We were able to laugh it off and chalk it up to, as weird as it seemed, stranger anxiety. We assured each other that next time it would be different since we got the awkward first meeting out of the way.
I wasn't sure if our real-life weirdness would seep in and distance our written selves at all. When she signed off with, "I wish I could see you all the time. You give the best hugs," I knew there was no need to worry.
The
Annie Get Your Gun trip was about nine months later. By that time, we had really stepped up the schmoop factor and our concurrent denials of lesbianism became more fervent. I mean, we hadn't actually kissed or anything so we weren't, you know, gay for each other or anything like that. But even without kissing or sex, our relationship was gayer than Billie Jean King, Melissa Etheridge and the entire Michigan Womyn's Music Festival combined.
Gifts of free-form poetry, incense and mix tapes containing inordinate amounts of Sarah McLachlan and, God help me, Jewel were shipped back and forth. Necklaces, bracelets and rings were exchanged. She sent me a silver band while she sported a Claddagh I sent her. It mattered not that it was a
fucking Irish wedding ring because she was "just my friend."
The
Annie Get Your Gun outing was nigh. At long last, she was back in town and we were going to spend longer than one hour together.
I stood in front of the Marriot Marquis with my friend waiting for her to arrive. As the meeting time approached, I felt increasingly light-headed and sick. I honestly thought I was going to have a big honking barf right there on Broadway.
"Are you okay? You don't look so good, Curly," my friend asked.
She knew of our somewhat unique friendship but she didn't know the extent of it at all. No one in my life did.
"I'm fine. It's just been a busy day and I haven't eaten a lot."
We moved out of the line of fire of the crowds and the Black Israelites (apparently she and I are both the Devil. Pass it on!) and I leaned up against a pole for support. Mercifully, the moment passed without so much as a dry heave.
She arrived with her father about 10 minutes late apologizing up and down for being tardy. A few months later, she would reveal that it wasn't subway problems that caused her delay but rather, because she was holed up in her hotel room dealing with a nervous stomach inspired by lil' ol' me. A ha! I was not alone in my bout of nausea.
My friend and her father bookended us inside the theater. We sat side by side. Even though we were in the presence of the performer who ultimately brought us together, neither of us could fully concentrate on Bernadette. We were acutely aware of each other during the entire show. Don't ask me the details about this musical. I can't recall any.
Instead, I noticed that she crossed her right leg over her left while she sat. Her right hand rested on top of her left in her lap. She was prone to barely audible squeals and gasps when the action on stage delighted her. She used Pantene shampoo. And she wore my ring.
Afterwards we went out for dinner. She sat diagonally from me across the table. And we exchanged nervous looks. Once again, we lacked a physical ease with each other but the presence of her father and my friend tempered our nerves. Slightly.
Occasionally I'd catch her eye and we'd share a moment. There was a palpable crackle of energy between us. She felt it too because we both blushed and looked away and then looked at each other again... about 20 or 30 times at least.
After dinner we said our good nights on Eighth Avenue. But unlike the last trip, we had more than just a drive-by planned. We refused to settle for just a couple of hours. We planned a night out, just the two of us. But that made the ending to our first night out no less bittersweet.
I shook her father's hand, she shook my friend's and then we turned to each other. We engaged in a tremendous lingering hug. I remember how her hand reached up and touched the back of my hair. She said, "Oh, I don't want you to leave yet." I could have lived in that moment forever.
We begrudgingly released the embrace and I reached out and softly cupped her cheeks with my one hand, gave a gentle squeeze and said, "Oh, what a face!" She became visbily flustered by my touch and stammered a little bit. It was beyond adorable.
I gave her a smile and said, "I'll see you on Monday."
>> Go to Part Five-- Part One
-- Part Two
-- Part Three
Labels: bernadette peters, dating, glbt, theater